When Public Trust Is Tested: Youth, Governance and the Growing Demand for Accountability
By Mushtaq Bala
The past week in Jammu and Kashmir has offered a revealing picture of the political and administrative challenges confronting the Union Territory. Beneath the routine announcements, political engagements and official assurances, a more significant question has begun to emerge: Is the distance between public expectations and governance becoming wider?
Perhaps nowhere is this question more visible than in the growing controversy surrounding the Finance Accounts Assistant (FAA) recruitment examination conducted by the Jammu and Kashmir Services Selection Board (JKSSB) on November 15.
For thousands of young aspirants, a government recruitment examination is not merely an academic exercise. It represents years of preparation, family sacrifices, financial expenditure and the hope of securing a respectable livelihood. When allegations of organised cheating emerge, the issue goes far beyond the functioning of an examination board. It strikes at the credibility of the entire recruitment system.
The police have reportedly arrested suspects in connection with an alleged electronic cheating network, while the JKSSB has maintained that the examination itself was not compromised and that the suspected attempt to use unfair means was detected and prevented. These are important distinctions, and the investigation must establish the facts rather than allow allegations to become verdicts.
Yet the Board’s explanation, however necessary, has not been sufficient to reassure the aspirants.
Their concern is rooted in a longer history of recruitment controversies, cancelled examinations and delayed accountability. For a generation that has repeatedly been asked to prepare, appear and wait, another assurance of procedural integrity is unlikely to restore confidence on its own.
The protests at Sher-e-Kashmir Park, joined by former MP Aga Syed Ruhullah Mehdi and subsequently attracting the attention of PDP president Mehbooba Mufti and other political voices, have brought the matter into sharper political focus. The reported removal of protesters from the site by police late Saturday has added another dimension to the controversy.
The government must understand that the real challenge is not simply to manage a protest but to address the grievance that brought young people onto the streets.
An elected government cannot remain distant from public disappointment.
There is a legitimate distinction between the administrative autonomy of a recruitment board and the political responsibility of the government. But autonomy cannot become a convenient shield against accountability. If the government can review the functioning of institutions, it must also be prepared to answer questions when those institutions face serious public criticism.
Chief Minister Omar Abdullah’s administration came to power amid considerable public expectations. People voted for an elected government because they wanted a more responsive system, a greater sense of participation and relief from the uncertainties that had characterised years of administration without an elected Assembly.
That mandate carries responsibilities.
The government may not directly control every operational decision of every recruitment agency, but it cannot remain a spectator when the credibility of public recruitment is questioned. It must ensure that the investigation is impartial, that the findings are made public and that anyone found guilty faces consequences, irrespective of position or influence.
At the same time, the demand for accountability must not turn into an indiscriminate suspension of every recruitment process. Thousands of deserving candidates are already waiting for employment. Their future cannot be held hostage to administrative indecision. The objective must be to protect the innocent, punish the guilty and restore confidence without creating another cycle of uncertainty.
Politics, meanwhile, has found an opportunity in the growing discontent.
The participation of opposition leaders in the aspirants’ agitation reflects the political importance of the issue. Aga Syed Ruhullah Mehdi’s presence is particularly significant in the context of his recent departure from the National Conference. Mehbooba Mufti’s intervention and the voices demanding an independent investigation have further widened the debate.
But the youth must not become merely an instrument of political competition.
Those now expressing solidarity with the protesting aspirants must also explain what they did, or failed to do, when they held positions of authority. Recruitment irregularities are not a new phenomenon in Jammu and Kashmir. The region has witnessed repeated controversies across successive administrations.
The question, therefore, is not which political party can make the strongest statement today. It is which political leadership is prepared to establish a system in which such controversies do not recur tomorrow.
There are other developments that deserve attention. The National Conference’s efforts to accommodate internal differences through advisory groups for legislators attached to ministers suggest that the ruling party is also dealing with questions of political coordination and representation. Internal consultation is healthy in a democratic organisation, but it must ultimately translate into better governance rather than remain an exercise in managing political dissatisfaction.
The distinction between party management and public administration must never be lost. People did not vote merely for a better-managed political organisation. They voted for a government capable of delivering.
Similarly, the Chief Minister’s recent emphasis on youth participation, engaged citizenship and the contribution of young professionals to nation-building at an educational convocation in New Delhi was an important message. But the most convincing way to engage young people is to ensure that their opportunities are determined by merit, not connections, influence or manipulation.
Words about empowering youth must find their reflection in institutions.
The situation in neighbouring Ladakh also deserves attention. Renewed protests and continuing demands for constitutional safeguards indicate that questions of representation, identity and political assurances remain important in the wider Himalayan region. Democratic engagement requires sustained dialogue, not merely occasional official interventions.
Meanwhile, society itself is confronting questions of accountability and dignity. The decision of Kashmir’s Waza Association to restrict wedding Wazwan services beyond 10 pm, citing the difficult working conditions faced by traditional chefs and their assistants, may appear to be a small social development. Yet it reflects a larger need to reconsider practices that have normalised inconvenience and exploitation in the name of tradition and social prestige.
These developments, though different in character, point towards one common principle: institutions, political leadership and society must remain answerable to the people affected by their decisions.
Kashmir’s greatest challenge is not a shortage of promises. It is the credibility of their delivery.
The administration must recognise that public patience is not unlimited. Young people cannot be expected to remain silent when their professional futures appear uncertain. Nor can every legitimate grievance be dismissed as political provocation.
The way forward is neither confrontation nor political grandstanding. It is transparent investigation, institutional reform, meaningful dialogue and visible accountability.
The FAA controversy should become an opportunity to establish a recruitment system that can withstand public scrutiny. The government should consider an independent and credible review of the allegations, publish the findings and introduce safeguards that leave no room for manipulation. The recruitment process must be protected, not paralysed.
Ultimately, the strength of an elected government is not measured by how effectively it defends itself against criticism. It is measured by how sincerely it responds when citizens question its performance.
The young aspirant sitting in protest, the parent waiting for a child’s appointment, the employee demanding fair treatment and the ordinary citizen seeking an answer from the administration are not asking for extraordinary privileges.
They are asking for fairness.
And fairness is not a political favour. It is the minimum obligation of democratic governance.
Mushtaq Bala
Editor-in-Chief
KASHMIR PEN
