• About
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
Thursday, November 19, 2026
No Result
View All Result
KashmirPEN
  • Home
  • Latest NewsLive
  • State News
  • COVID-19
  • Kashmir
  • National
  • International
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Weekly
    • Perception
    • Perspective
    • Narrative
    • Concern
    • Nostalgia
    • Tribute
    • Viewpoint
    • Outlook
    • Opinion
    • Sufi Saints of Kashmir
    • Personality
    • Musing
    • Society
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Cover Story
    • Book Review
    • Heritage
    • Art & Poetry
  • Home
  • Latest NewsLive
  • State News
  • COVID-19
  • Kashmir
  • National
  • International
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Weekly
    • Perception
    • Perspective
    • Narrative
    • Concern
    • Nostalgia
    • Tribute
    • Viewpoint
    • Outlook
    • Opinion
    • Sufi Saints of Kashmir
    • Personality
    • Musing
    • Society
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Cover Story
    • Book Review
    • Heritage
    • Art & Poetry
KashmirPEN
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Weekly Editorial

Capitalist Impasse

Kashmir Pen by Kashmir Pen
1 hour ago
in Editorial, Weekly
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Capitalist Impasse
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The worldwide student and youth protests reflect the fact
that neoliberalism, which had been so pervasively adopted,
has finally run its course and has reached a dead end.

ADVERTISEMENT

Prabhat Patnaik

Not just in India but over large parts of the world, students and youth are on the streets protesting against the regimes under which they live. The simultaneity and pervasiveness of these protests would suggest a common world conjuncture underlying them; such a commonality of conjuncture is indeed explicitly underscored by certain common grievances that these movements articulate no matter where they occur, such as the absence of employment opportunities and the appalling conditions under which education is imparted to the majority of students.
The common conjuncture producing these movements is the stasis of neoliberal capitalism. The worldwide student and youth protests reflect the fact that neoliberalism, which had been so pervasively adopted, has finally run its course and has reached a dead end.
To be sure, the dead end of neoliberal capitalism has not taken the form of a Great Depression and mass unemployment, as the dead end of pre-War ‘laissez-faire capitalism’ had taken. It has rather assumed the form of a prolonged stagnation, in the course of which the working people have been mired in growing unemployment and stagnant or declining real incomes. The decade between 2011 and 2019 — that is, even if we do not take into account the effect of the pandemic — had seen the lowest annual growth rate of world gross domestic product for any decade since the Second World War, a rate not much higher than world population growth. This virtual stagnation in per capita real income in a period of widening income inequalities has spelt distress for vast masses of people across the world, including even in advanced capitalist countries; indeed, the stagnation itself is caused by the widening income inequalities that keep down consumption demand and hence aggregate demand.
The economist, Joseph Stiglitz, estimates that the average real wage of a male American worker in 2011 was marginally lower than in 1968. This is hardly surprising since neoliberalism, entailing relatively unrestricted movement of capital, including finance, across the borders of countries, makes capital into an international entity while the working classes continue to be organized along national lines. This causes an immense shift in the balance of class power; and rising income inequalities reflect this shift.
Neoliberalism not only pushes economies into stagnation through rising income inequality but it also incapacitates the State from taking measures to overcome such stagnation. John Maynard Keynes had pinned his hopes on State intervention to maintain high levels of employment in capitalist countries so that the appeal of a socialist revolution would disappear altogether; and social democracy had done precisely this to usher in high employment and growth in the aftermath of the War.
For Keynesian State intervention to work, however, larger State expenditure cannot be financed by taxing the working people, who more or less consume their entire income, for then there would be no net increase in aggregate demand. Larger State expenditure would boost aggregate demand only if it is financed either through a larger fiscal deficit (in which case nobody is being taxed for it) or through taxes on the rich (in which case there is no equivalent reduction in private consumption since a large part of the increased tax is paid from a reduction in savings).
Globalized finance, however, is opposed to both these methods of raising resources for financing larger State expenditure. It opposes larger taxes on the rich since financiers are among the richest people and it opposes fiscal deficits beyond a small percentage of the GDP (usually 3% these days which is institutionalized through ‘fiscal responsibility’ legislation) since State expenditure financed in this manner has the effect of delegitimizing the role of capitalists.
The point, though, is this: since under neoliberalism globalized finance faces the nation-state, there is a shift in the balance of power in favour of capital, exactly as happens in the case of the nationally-organized working class; capital’s writ must run, otherwise it would go elsewhere. The State therefore kowtows before finance and is unable to counter the stagnation, which persists and marks a dead end for neoliberal capitalism.
But, it may be argued, if each nation-state is powerless before capital that is now international, can’t a surrogate world-state, consisting of several nation-states acting in unison, introduce a coordinated fiscal stimulus to overcome stagnation? Finance, after all, cannot then shift to the moon; it will have to accept the expansionary policies of such a surrogate world-state.
Such a proposal for a coordinated fiscal stimulus by several nation-states acting in unison had been mooted by a group of German trade unions during the Great Depression of the 1930s and also by John Maynard Keynes. But it was ignored at the time. It is the fascists who came to power in Germany and Japan that overcame Depression in their respective countries by vastly expanding deficit-financed State expenditure on militarisation; this phenomenon is sometimes referred to as ‘military Keynesianism’.
Today, when the need for such a ‘surrogate world-state’ action is more urgent than in the 1930s, nobody is even talking about it. Instead, we have the leading capitalist country of the world pursuing ‘beggar-thy-neighbour’ policies aimed at exporting unemployment to other countries, especially countries of the Global South, by imposing heavy tariffs on their goods sold in the American market. There is, in short, no coherent vision of a post-neoliberal world or any strategy for arriving at it; there is not even a whiff of discussion about the dead end of neoliberal capitalism, which makes this dead end even more inescapable. The only capitalist strategy in this context has been to promote neofascism to crush the protests breaking out. This, however, provides an opportunity to the Left to intervene in the situation to transcend neoliberal capitalism and begin a journey towards socialism.

Prabhat Patnaik is Professor Emeritus, Centre for Economic Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi

Previous Post

MBBS. The question is no longer, “Can Ibecome a doctor? “The question is,“Should I become a doctor? “That Distinction is Crucial.

Next Post

WHEN WARTAAV BECOMES MEASURE OF A RELATIONSHIP

Kashmir Pen

Kashmir Pen

Next Post
WHEN WARTAAV BECOMES MEASURE OF A RELATIONSHIP

WHEN WARTAAV BECOMES MEASURE OF A RELATIONSHIP

Leave Comment
ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Youtube RSS

©2020 KashmirPEN | Made with ❤️ by Uzair.XYZ

imunify-bot-check
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • State News
  • COVID-19
  • Kashmir
  • National
  • International
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Weekly
    • Perception
    • Perspective
    • Narrative
    • Concern
    • Nostalgia
    • Tribute
    • Viewpoint
    • Outlook
    • Opinion
    • Sufi Saints of Kashmir
    • Personality
    • Musing
    • Society
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Cover Story
    • Book Review
    • Heritage
    • Art & Poetry

©2020 KashmirPEN | Made with ❤️ by Uzair.XYZ