POWER OF POSITIVITY Is MEDICINE STILL A BLESSED PROFESSION ?
Rethinking Medicine as a Career: Why MBBS Is No Longer the Unquestioned Dream
of India’s Top Students
Dr. Fiaz Maqbool Fazili
A few days ago, I watched a group of young students and anxious parents protesting over admissions to medical colleges. Their determination was unmistakable. Many had spent years preparing for competitive examinations; some families had invested enormous financial and emotional resources in the dream of seeing their children wear the coveted white coat. As I observed them, a simple question came to mind: Do these students truly understand the career they are fighting so hard to enter? More importantly, do their parents?
For generations, MBBS was considered the gold standard of professional success in India. It promised social respect, stable employment, financial security, and an opportunity to serve humanity. The medical profession enjoyed a unique status. A doctor was not merely a professional but often the most trusted figure in a community.
Today, however, medicine stands at a crossroads. It remains among the noblest professions, yet it is no longer the unquestioned first choice for many of the country’s brightest minds. The reasons are neither mysterious nor difficult to understand.
The changing aspirations of Generation Z and the manner they approach career decisions differently from their parents. They evaluate professions not only by prestige but also by quality of life, earning potential, growth opportunities, flexibility, and work-life balance.Students today compare medicine with engineering, management, technology, entrepreneurship, artificial intelligence, finance, law, civil services, and emerging digital professions. Many of these careers offer earlier financial independence, greater mobility, lower educational costs, and fewer years of uncertainty. This comparison has fundamentally altered the perception of MBBS. The question is no longer, “Can I become a doctor? “The question is, “Should I become a doctor? “That distinction is crucial.
On the long and uncertain road, A student completes higher secondary education, clears the highly competitive NEET examination, enters MBBS, and spends five and a half years obtaining the basic medical degree. But MBBS is only the beginning.A doctor who wishes to remain competitive generally needs postgraduate specialization. Obtaining a postgraduate seat requires another intense national-level examination. Many spend one or more years preparing. If successful, another three years are devoted to postgraduate training. For those pursuing Specialization and super specialization, the journey extends further.The result is that many doctors spend 10 to 15 of their most productive years in continuous examinations, training, and uncertainty before securing a stable professional footing.
By contrast, many engineers, management graduates, software professionals, and entrepreneurs establish careers, acquire homes, support families, and accumulate savings long before their medical counterparts complete formal training.The opportunity cost is enormous.
On value Stream mapping (VSM), and priority matrix we see the great mismatch on effort versus reward plotting. Every profession demands hard work. Medicine demands extraordinary hard work.Medical students routinely endure sleep deprivation, academic stress, emotional exhaustion, and immense responsibility. Residents in busy hospitals often work 18 to 24-hour shifts. Surgeons, physicians, emergency specialists, and critical care doctors frequently sacrifice weekends, holidays, family events, and personal well-being.Yet many young doctors increasingly feel that the rewards are disproportionate to the sacrifices.The traditional understanding was straightforward: work hard, qualify as a doctor, and success would naturally follow. That equation is no longer automatic.
Job markets are becoming increasingly competitive. The expansion of medical colleges has increased the number of graduates. Corporate healthcare has altered employment patterns. The costs of setting up private practice continue to rise. Urban markets are saturated while rural healthcare remains inadequately structured and incentivized.Many young doctors find themselves asking whether the return justifies the investment. Why are some doctors choosing civil services even after graduating in Medicine, but not vice versa? This question always baffles my mind. One of the most striking trends in recent years has been the growing number of doctors entering civil services.Names such as Dr., SF, SA,SAR, RS etc (names held (and several other physician-bureaucrats have demonstrated that medical graduates can achieve remarkable success beyond healthcare. This development often attracts criticism from those who argue that a medical seat has been wasted. That argument oversimplifies a complex reality.
Doctors bring unique strengths to public administration. They understand public health, epidemiology, healthcare systems, social determinants of disease, and human suffering in ways few others do. But the attraction of civil services goes beyond public service. Civil services offer stability, authority, leadership opportunities, defined career progression, housing benefits, and societal influence. Most importantly, they provide a certainty that medicine increasingly struggles to guarantee. After years of examinations and professional uncertainty, many doctors understandably seek alternative paths that offer greater predictability and impact. One cannot blame them for making a rational career choice.
The Corporate Challenge has added a new dimension to compassionate medicine and challenges of empathetic ethical medical practice. Another factor altering the attractiveness of medicine is the growing influence of corporate healthcare. Large hospital chains have transformed healthcare delivery across India. While they have improved infrastructure and access to advanced technologies, they have also changed the nature of medical practice. Many young doctors find themselves operating within systems where administrative targets, productivity metrics, and commercial considerations increasingly influence professional life. Medicine remains patient-centred in principle, but many practitioners feel constrained by institutional realities. This tension contributes to professional dissatisfaction and burnout.
Is Medicine Losing Its Future Value? Most FAQ in my box from many young aspirants.
The answer is both yes and no. Yes, because medicine no longer guarantees automatic prosperity, rapid career progression, or unquestioned social authority. Yes, because technology, artificial intelligence, telemedicine, robotics, and digital diagnostics are transforming traditional models of healthcare delivery. Yes, because career alternatives available to talented students have expanded dramatically.
But the answer is also no. No profession can completely replace the physician’s role in human society. Compassionate, empathetic, ready to extend help with tender loving carte alleviation pain and suffering that had rated him or her high as, “messiah”. Machines may assist diagnosis. Algorithms may process data. Artificial intelligence may improve efficiency. Yet patients will continue to seek human judgment, empathy, reassurance, ethical decision-making, and trust. The essence of medicine remains deeply human. That fundamental truth is unlikely to change.
Reality check! for parents, perhaps the most important message is for parents as many still continue to pursue MBBS for their children because it represented security in the previous generation. But careers cannot be chosen based on yesterday’s realities. A student should not enter medicine merely because relatives expect it, society glorifies it, or family prestige depends upon it. Medicine is not a status symbol., nor fetches a good spouse by default. It is a lifelong commitment. It demands patience, resilience, sacrifice, compassion, intellectual curiosity, and an acceptance of delayed gratification. If these qualities are absent, the journey can become deeply frustrating.
The final message from this piece should be, Look Before You Leap. Prospective medical students must ask themselves several honest questions. Do I genuinely enjoy science and medicine? Am I prepared for more than a decade of training? Can I tolerate repeated competitive examinations? Am I willing to work long hours under stressful conditions? Can I delay financial gratification compared to peers in other professions? Do I derive satisfaction from helping people, even when the rewards are not immediate? If the answer to these questions is yes, medicine may still be one of the most fulfilling professions in the world. If not, there are many other careers where talent, intelligence, and hard work can flourish.
Medicine Remains Blessed, But Not Easy Pie To Bite .Despite its challenges, medicine continues to offer something few professions can provide: the privilege of relieving suffering and restoring hope Every successful surgery, every recovered patient, every life saved, and every family comforted creates a sense of purpose that cannot be measured solely in financial terms. The profession may have lost some of its traditional aura. It may no longer guarantee the certainty it once did. It may no longer be the default destination for every top-ranking student. Yet it remains a blessed profession for those who enter it with open eyes and informed expectations. The challenge before India is not merely to produce more doctors. It is to create a healthcare ecosystem where talented young people do not feel compelled to abandon medicine in search of stability, dignity, and opportunity elsewhere.The white coat still carries honour. But before aspiring doctors wear it, they deserve the truth about what lies beneath it. Choosing medicine should not be an emotional decision. It should be an informed one. That is the conversation India must urgently begin.
The Author is Sr. Consultant Surgeon, an Expert in Healthcare policy analysis ,and planning, can be approached at drfiazfazili@gmail.com
—

