Ahmad Ayaz
The repeated incidents of rotten, unhygienic and potentially harmful meat being supplied and sold in Kashmir are deeply disturbing. The recent seizure of rotten meat at Budgam Railway Station has once again brought this serious issue into public focus, raising questions not only about food safety and administrative oversight but also about the moral and ethical values governing our society.
What makes the latest incident particularly concerning is that this is not the first time rotten meat has been seized at Budgam Railway Station. Earlier too, substantial quantities of rotten meat were reportedly seized at different locations across Kashmir. This raises an important question: What lessons have we learnt from those incidents? What action was taken against those responsible, and what preventive measures were introduced to ensure that such incidents do not recur?
If similar incidents continue to surface despite previous seizures and official action, it is evident that something more fundamental is missing from the system. Merely confiscating consignments, registering cases and issuing statements cannot provide a lasting solution. The entire supply chain, including procurement, transportation, storage and distribution, needs to be examined.
However, there is another dimension to this issue that deserves equal, if not greater, attention.
Primarily, this is a matter of honesty, commercial ethics and administrative responsibility. Equally important is the question of how effectively society, and religious leaders in particular, have discharged their responsibility of inculcating honesty, integrity and a sense of moral accountability among people.
This is not merely a matter of hygiene, food safety or unfair trade practices. It is fundamentally an issue of humanity, ethics and respect for human life.
Beyond food safety: A question of honesty and commercial ethics
Selling rotten or unfit meat to unsuspecting consumers, particularly when the seller is aware of its condition, is not simply an irregular business practice. It is a serious betrayal of public trust and a violation of basic human values.
An ordinary consumer purchases meat with the expectation that it is fresh, hygienic and safe for consumption. Families spend their hard-earned money on food, trusting that the seller will not compromise their health for personal profit.
Knowingly selling rotten meat as fresh is therefore an act of deception that can expose innocent people, including children and elderly persons, to serious health risks.
The pursuit of profit cannot justify putting another person’s life or health in danger. Business is meant to provide a legitimate livelihood, not to exploit the ignorance or vulnerability of consumers.
The larger question is whether commercial ethics and basic human values are gradually losing their place in our society. If making money becomes more important than honesty, responsibility and concern for fellow human beings, the problem goes much deeper than a few dishonest traders.
A society’s moral strength is reflected not merely in its religious identity or outward practices but also in how its members conduct themselves in everyday dealings.
The responsibility of religious scholars: Beyond condemnation
The role of religious scholars and community leaders deserves particular attention in this context.
Whenever such incidents come to light, religious scholars understandably condemn the practice and demand strict government action. Their intervention is justified and welcome. However, should their responsibility end with condemning an incident or seeking punitive action from the government?
Religious leadership carries a much wider social and moral responsibility. It is equally important for religious scholars to examine what role they have played in developing honesty, integrity and ethical conduct within society.
Have issues such as dishonesty in trade, adulteration of food, exploitation of consumers, bribery, cheating and violation of public rights received the sustained attention they deserve in our mosques, sermons and religious gatherings?
Have our religious institutions made sufficient efforts to educate traders and business communities that earning a livelihood must also be accompanied by honesty, transparency and consideration for the health and rights of others?
Islam places great emphasis on honesty in commercial transactions. The Holy Quran condemns dishonesty in weights and measures, while the teachings of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) strongly prohibit deception and concealment of defects.
A well-known Hadith in Sahih Muslim describes how the Prophet (PBUH), upon discovering that a food seller had concealed wet grain beneath apparently good grain, instructed him to expose the defective portion. The underlying message was clear: a seller must not deceive a buyer by concealing the quality or condition of what is being sold.
The same principle applies to meat and other food products. Selling something known to be rotten or harmful while presenting it as fresh is fundamentally contrary to the ethical principles of Islam.
The consumption of halal food is not determined merely by the permissibility of the animal. Cleanliness, safe handling and protection from harmful contamination are equally important considerations.
Religious scholars therefore have an important role in promoting these values continuously, rather than limiting their intervention to issuing statements after a scandal has surfaced.
Their responsibility is not to conduct inspections or assume the regulatory powers of government departments. It is to educate, guide and help create a society in which dishonesty and exploitation are morally unacceptable.
Social responsibility: The role of civil society and citizens
The responsibility cannot, however, be placed entirely upon the government or religious scholars. Society itself must undertake serious introspection.
Civil society organisations, market associations, community representatives, media organisations and ordinary citizens all have an important role in preventing such practices.
Unfortunately, our collective response to many public issues often remains temporary. An incident occurs, public outrage follows, statements are issued and action is demanded. Once the immediate controversy subsides, the issue gradually disappears from public attention.
This approach does little to address the underlying problem.
Civil society organisations should maintain pressure on the administration until the findings of investigations and the outcome of previous cases are made public. They should seek answers about the measures taken to prevent recurrence and ensure that the issue does not disappear once media attention shifts elsewhere.
Market associations must also take responsibility for discouraging unethical commercial practices among their members. Honest traders should not be allowed to suffer because of competitors who compromise quality and public health to increase their profits.
The media, too, must go beyond reporting individual seizures. It should investigate the larger supply networks, follow up on earlier cases and question the effectiveness of regulatory mechanisms.
Consumers have an equally important responsibility. They should remain vigilant, report suspicious practices to the competent authorities and avoid spreading unverified allegations against individuals or establishments.
Social responsibility means recognising that public welfare is not exclusively the government’s concern. Every individual and institution has a role in protecting the common good.
Administrative responsibility and accountability
Moral and social responsibility cannot substitute for administrative accountability. The government has a clear statutory obligation to protect public health, and the concerned departments must discharge their responsibilities effectively.
The authorities responsible for food safety, veterinary services, municipal regulation and market inspections must ensure that meat entering the market comes from lawful sources, is properly inspected, transported hygienically and stored under appropriate conditions.
The entire supply chain requires scrutiny. Where does the meat originate? Who is responsible for its transportation? Where is it stored? Which establishments receive it? Are the necessary inspections being conducted at every stage?
These questions become particularly important when similar incidents have reportedly occurred in the past.
The authorities should also review earlier cases and disclose what action was taken against those responsible. Were investigations completed? Were prosecutions initiated? Were the supply networks identified? Were regulatory deficiencies corrected?
Simply confiscating a consignment or arresting a few individuals may not be sufficient if the larger network responsible for procurement and distribution remains unidentified.
Equally important is the question of supervisory accountability. If unsafe meat repeatedly reaches consumers despite the existence of regulatory mechanisms, the performance of officials entrusted with enforcement must also be examined.
Inspections should not be conducted merely in response to media reports or public outrage. They must be regular, professional and transparent. Scientific testing, proper documentation and effective monitoring of storage and transportation facilities should form an integral part of the system.
No trader, official or influential individual should be allowed to escape accountability if wrongdoing is established.
The need for moral and social introspection
The rotten meat controversy should also prompt a broader discussion about the standards of honesty and integrity prevailing in our society.
We often demand accountability from others but rarely examine our own responsibilities. Dishonesty in trade, manipulation of weights and measures, adulteration of essential commodities and exploitation of consumers are not isolated problems. They reflect a wider erosion of ethical values.
Religious institutions, educational establishments, families and community organisations must all contribute to rebuilding these values.
Religious discourse should give adequate attention to the rights of fellow human beings, honest earnings, commercial integrity and the responsibility of protecting others from harm. Similarly, social organisations should work towards creating awareness that unethical business practices are not merely violations of commercial regulations but also betrayals of public trust.
The influence of religious scholars in Kashmiri society is considerable. That influence should be used constructively to promote ethical behaviour and social responsibility, particularly among those engaged in business and trade.
The question is not whether religious scholars should condemn such incidents. They certainly should. The more important question is whether their continuing engagement with society has been sufficiently effective in preventing the moral and ethical failures that make such incidents possible.
A collective responsibility, not a temporary reaction
The repeated seizure of rotten meat in Kashmir should serve as a wake-up call for everyone concerned.
The government must ensure effective regulation and accountability. Traders must uphold honesty and commercial ethics. Religious scholars must contribute to moral education and social reform. Civil society must maintain public pressure, while citizens must remain vigilant about their rights and responsibilities.
Above all, the lessons of previous incidents must not be forgotten. Every new seizure should lead to a review of earlier investigations, identification of systemic failures and concrete preventive measures.
It is not enough to demand punishment after the damage has been done. The real objective must be to prevent such practices from occurring in the first place.
The most important question is not simply who supplied or sold the rotten meat, but why such practices continue despite earlier incidents, public outrage and official action. What has the administration done to prevent their recurrence, and how effectively have society and its religious leaders contributed towards inculcating honesty, integrity and a sense of responsibility among people?
Unless we address the administrative failures as well as the deeper erosion of commercial ethics and social values, the controversy may fade from public memory, only to resurface in another form.
Ultimately, protecting human health and dignity is a collective responsibility. A society that places profit above human life, and reacts to wrongdoing only after it is exposed, must seriously reconsider its moral and social priorities.
The author is a Columnist and national tv debater. He can be reached at ahmadayaz08@gmail.com

