• About
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
Thursday, November 19, 2026
No Result
View All Result
KashmirPEN
  • Home
  • Latest NewsLive
  • State News
  • COVID-19
  • Kashmir
  • National
  • International
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Weekly
    • Perception
    • Perspective
    • Narrative
    • Concern
    • Nostalgia
    • Tribute
    • Viewpoint
    • Outlook
    • Opinion
    • Sufi Saints of Kashmir
    • Personality
    • Musing
    • Society
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Cover Story
    • Book Review
    • Heritage
    • Art & Poetry
  • Home
  • Latest NewsLive
  • State News
  • COVID-19
  • Kashmir
  • National
  • International
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Weekly
    • Perception
    • Perspective
    • Narrative
    • Concern
    • Nostalgia
    • Tribute
    • Viewpoint
    • Outlook
    • Opinion
    • Sufi Saints of Kashmir
    • Personality
    • Musing
    • Society
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Cover Story
    • Book Review
    • Heritage
    • Art & Poetry
KashmirPEN
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Weekly Cover Story

WHEN MOSQUES BECOME POLITICAL TARGETS

Kashmir Pen by Kashmir Pen
8 minutes ago
in Cover Story, Weekly
Reading Time: 5 mins read
WHEN MOSQUES BECOME POLITICAL TARGETS
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Shagun Parihar’s Kishtwar Remarks Raise Questions of Evidence, Accountability and the Price of Communal Politics..Mushtaq Bala

ADVERTISEMENT

Mushtaq Bala

There are moments when a public representative’s words carry consequences far beyond the immediate political controversy. In a sensitive and socially diverse region like Jammu and Kashmir, a statement involving religion, places of worship and communal identity cannot be treated as just another political remark. It demands scrutiny, responsibility and, above all, evidence.
The controversy surrounding BJP MLA Shagun Parihar’s remarks following the killing of two Special Police Officers in Kishtwar has brought this uncomfortable question back into public debate: How far can political representatives go in making allegations that potentially place an entire community under suspicion?
The deaths of SPOs Babi Chand and Rashpal Kumar in the Dachhan area are undoubtedly tragic. Their families deserve answers, the circumstances surrounding their deaths must be thoroughly investigated, and those responsible must be identified and brought to justice. There should be no ambiguity about the seriousness of the incident or the need for accountability.
But the investigation into a security-related crime and the public attribution of suspicion to a religious institution are two entirely different matters.
At a wreath-laying ceremony for the deceased personnel, Shagun Parihar reportedly claimed that announcements had been made from a mosque before the killings. She further suggested that someone was passing information and leaking intelligence from the area. These remarks immediately raised concerns because they brought a place of worship into a sensitive security-related narrative without publicly identifying the mosque, the persons allegedly involved or the evidence supporting the claim.
The question is straightforward: If such announcements were indeed made, where were they made, who made them, what exactly was announced and what evidence supports the allegation?
These are questions that deserve answers from any public representative making such a serious assertion.
A mosque is not an ordinary public platform. It is a place of worship and an institution that holds deep religious and emotional significance for millions. Associating it with violence, intelligence leaks or hostility towards another community without establishing the facts can create suspicion far beyond the individuals who may actually be responsible for a crime.
This is precisely why public representatives must exercise greater restraint than ordinary citizens.
When Allegations Become a Matter of Public Responsibility
The response to Parihar’s remarks has been significant. Jammu and Kashmir minister Sakina Itoo described the statement as deeply unfortunate, irresponsible and uncalled for. She urged the BJP legislator to withdraw her remarks and apologise to the people of Jammu and Kashmir, particularly the Muslim community.
Itoo’s intervention brought the debate to a fundamental issue: the responsibility of elected representatives to preserve the region’s tradition of brotherhood and peaceful coexistence.
Jammu and Kashmir Congress president Tariq Hamid Karra also criticised the remarks, while the National Conference demanded accountability and legal action.
Importantly, objections did not come exclusively from political opponents. BJP leader Jahanzaib Sirwal also questioned the allegation, describing it as factually unsubstantiated. The Islami Markaz-e-Majlis Shura Kishtwar, headed by Jama Masjid Imam Maulana Farooq Ahmad Kichloo, rejected the claim and sought a public apology.
When even voices from within the BJP’s own political circles question the basis of such an allegation, it becomes all the more necessary that the matter be addressed through evidence rather than political confrontation.
The Unanswered Question of an Apology
Sakina Itoo’s appeal for withdrawal and an apology was not merely a demand for political courtesy. It was an appeal for responsibility in a region where communal harmony is a shared social asset.
An apology, in such circumstances, should not be viewed as a defeat or surrender. It is an acknowledgement that public words have consequences and that elected representatives must be willing to correct themselves when their statements create apprehension or cannot be substantiated.
If the MLA possesses credible information, the appropriate course is to place it before the investigating agencies and allow the law to take its course. If the allegation cannot be substantiated, withdrawing it would be an equally necessary act of responsibility.
As of the time of writing, the reports reviewed have not recorded a public withdrawal or apology from Parihar. The absence of such a clarification leaves the controversy unresolved.
The BJP leadership, too, has a responsibility to clarify its position. Silence on allegations involving religious institutions and communal sensitivities does little to reassure a society that expects its political representatives to protect social harmony.
Kishtwar Cannot Afford the Politics of Suspicion
Kishtwar and the wider Chenab Valley have a social history in which communities of different faiths have lived alongside one another through generations of shared experiences, neighbourhood relationships and cultural exchanges.
That relationship cannot be taken for granted.
The region has witnessed difficult periods and understands the consequences of mistrust. Its people do not need political narratives that encourage one community to look at another through the lens of suspicion.
The killing of two SPOs should unite people in demanding justice, not create an atmosphere in which religious institutions or entire communities are made subjects of suspicion without evidence.
There is also a larger principle at stake. If a mosque can be publicly associated with an alleged security conspiracy without substantiation, tomorrow any religious institution could become the subject of similar allegations. Such a precedent would be dangerous for every community, irrespective of its religious identity.
The responsibility of the administration is equally important. Any information regarding alleged announcements must be independently examined. If there is evidence of unlawful activity, the perpetrators must face the law. If there is none, the public deserves clarity.
Political Accountability Cannot Be Selective
Democracy gives elected representatives the freedom to raise concerns, question security arrangements and demand answers from the administration. That freedom, however, comes with an obligation to distinguish between suspicion and established fact.
A legislator represents all citizens of her constituency, irrespective of religion. Her words should therefore inspire confidence among all sections of society, not create an impression that one community is being collectively placed under suspicion.
The same standard must apply to every political party. No party should exploit the tragedy of a killing to promote a communal narrative, and no political organisation should be allowed to escape scrutiny merely because its allegations are presented in the language of national security.
The security of citizens, the dignity of religious institutions and the preservation of communal harmony are not competing interests. They are equally important responsibilities of a democratic society.
The Larger Question
Jammu and Kashmir has paid a heavy price for mistrust, violence and social divisions. Its people understand that peace is not maintained through speeches alone but through responsible conduct, institutional credibility and mutual respect.
The demand for justice for the slain SPOs must remain uncompromised. Equally, the dignity of religious institutions must not be compromised through allegations that have yet to be substantiated.
Shagun Parihar has every right to demand answers about the killings. But she must also be prepared to answer questions about the basis of her own allegations.
The issue is no longer simply whether a minister has demanded an apology or whether a legislator chooses to offer one. It is about the standards of public conduct that Jammu and Kashmir expects from those elected to represent its people.
In a society as sensitive as ours, evidence must precede accusation, accountability must accompany authority, and political ambition must never be allowed to come at the cost of communal trust.
The people of Kishtwar deserve justice. The people of Jammu and Kashmir deserve truth. And every religious institution deserves protection from allegations that cannot withstand the test of evidence.

Mushtaq Bala is Editor-in-Chief of Kashmir Pen, an award-winning filmmaker, cultural commentator, and advocate for peace through narrative media.

Previous Post

Fayaz Dilbar:A Multifaceted Creative Genius — A Journey Through Literature, Theatre And Journalism

Next Post

Window Bonding

Kashmir Pen

Kashmir Pen

Next Post
Window Bonding

Window Bonding

Leave Comment
ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Youtube RSS

©2020 KashmirPEN | Made with ❤️ by Uzair.XYZ

imunify-bot-check
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • State News
  • COVID-19
  • Kashmir
  • National
  • International
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Weekly
    • Perception
    • Perspective
    • Narrative
    • Concern
    • Nostalgia
    • Tribute
    • Viewpoint
    • Outlook
    • Opinion
    • Sufi Saints of Kashmir
    • Personality
    • Musing
    • Society
    • Editorial
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Cover Story
    • Book Review
    • Heritage
    • Art & Poetry

©2020 KashmirPEN | Made with ❤️ by Uzair.XYZ